I want to introduce you to a grid for viewing the commands of the Bible that has been immensely helpful to me. This gospel grid serves as a filter through which we view every command in Scripture, ensuring that we neither fall into the error of legalism (self-reliant obedience) nor the error of license (disregarding obedience altogether). Instead, this grid leads us to a diligent dependence on Jesus—for both the grace of forgiveness and the grace of empowerment to obey.
Three Possible Responses to a Biblical Command
When you encounter a command in Scripture, such as “Do not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good” (Romans 12:21), you can respond in one of three ways:
1. Legalism: “I will try my very best, in my own strength, to overcome evil with good.”
This is attempting to obey apart from Christ, trusting in self-effort.
This is living under the law, rather than under grace.
Inevitably, you will fall into self-righteous pride because you will believe that you are good at keeping the Law or you will fall into self-deprecating despair because you will realize that your best efforts are never good enough.
2. License: “This command is impossible to obey consistently, so I don’t really need to worry about it.”
This is abusing God’s grace rather than submitting to it.
It treats biblical commands as mere ideals or suggestions rather than binding expressions of God’s will.
It leads to excusing sin instead of fighting sin and pursuing obedience.
3. Gospel: “I will view this command through the lens of the Gospel—seeing both my inability and Christ’s sufficiency.”
Instead of relying on self-effort or dismissing obedience, the Gospel leads us to depend on Jesus for both forgiveness and power.
The Gospel Grid: Four Steps for Viewing Every Command
1. God: Recognizing the Divine Logic of His Commands
“Why does He command this? How does this command reflect His character?”
Every command in Scripture flows from God’s holy character and reflects His moral will.
Because He is King, we are obligated to obey. Because He is a Good King, His commands are for my good.
Example (Romans 12:21): God commands me not to be overcome by evil, but to overcome evil with good because He is the God who conquers evil through righteousness and grace (Psalm 37:27-28).
2. Guilt: Recognizing My Absolute Inability to Obey on My Own
“Why can’t I, in and of my own strength, obey this command?”
My heart is prone to selfishness, resentment, and retaliation rather than overcoming evil with good.
I am often tempted to fight evil with more evil, responding in anger, bitterness, or revenge.
Example: When I am mistreated, my natural instinct is not to show kindness but to seek payback. Even when I outwardly restrain myself, I often harbor resentment in my heart rather than overcoming evil with true goodness.
3. Grace: Recognizing Christ’s Perfect Obedience in My Place
“How did Jesus perfectly succeed where I failed?”
Jesus obeyed this command perfectly—He never retaliated, even when treated unjustly. (1 Peter 2:22-23)
At the cross, Jesus bore the full weight of evil upon Himself, responding not with vengeance but with a prayer for forgiveness (Luke 23:34)
Because of Christ’s perfect obedience, God now accepts me in Him, treating me as if I had perfectly obeyed this command.
4. Gratitude: Being fueled by the motivation of the Gospel to pursue obedience
"How does the Gospel motivate me to put off sin and put on righteousness?"
Because Jesus died for my sinful desire for vengeance, I can now put my bitterness and retaliation to death—not by willpower, but by the Spirit’s power (Romans 8:13).
Because Jesus rose in victory, I can now walk in newness of life, empowered to respond to evil with goodness (Romans 6:4).
The more I meditate on God’s grace, the more I am motivated by love rather than anger.
Our pleasure and our duty,
Though opposite before,
Since we have seen His beauty
Are joined to part no more.
To see the law by Christ fulfilled
And hear His pardoning voice,
Transforms a slave into a child,
And duty into choice.
(John Newton)
How This Grid Protects Us from Legalism and License
Legalism says, “Try harder to obey.”
The Gospel says, “Christ obeyed for you, and now enables your obedience.”License says, “You can’t obey, so don’t worry about it.”
The Gospel says, “You can’t obey on your own, but in Christ, you are empowered by the Spirit to obey.”Legalism seeks obedience for acceptance.
The Gospel says, “Obedience flows from acceptance in Christ.”License excuses sin in the name of grace.
The Gospel says, “Grace is not only pardon for sin but power to fight sin and pursue righteousness.”
Living in the Gospel Grid
When you encounter any command in Scripture, filter it through these four questions:
God – Why does He command this? How does this command reflect His character?
Guilt – Why can’t I, in and of my own strength, obey this command?
Grace – How did Jesus perfectly succeed where I failed?
Gratitude – How does the Gospel motivate me to put off sin and put on righteousness?
This is how we study and seek to apply the commands of the Bible rightly, avoiding both self-reliance and self-indulgence, and growing in Christ-centered obedience.